How far will Trump go to erase DEI in the workplace?

Benefits experts were quick to defend the future of diversity, equity and inclusion programs in the U.S. following the reelection of President Donald Trump in November. But as corporations and government agencies pull back from DEI programs, optimism has been replaced by fear that such efforts won't survive past 2025.

Major companies like Walmart and McDonald's have abandoned previous diversity benchmarks under pressure from Trump's executive orders dismantling DEI programs across the federal government, claiming white candidates are discriminated against in favor of diverse hires that are based on quotas rather than qualifications.

The series of orders released in January, which include "Ending Radical and Wasteful Government DEI Programs and Preferencing," "Defending Women from Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government" and "Ending Illegal Discrimination and Restoring Merit-Based Opportunity" all aim to dismantle policies that sought to recruit staffers from a broader background.

In speaking with Employee Benefit News' Deanna Cuadra, Ann Olivarius, women's rights attorney, chair and senior partner at McAllister Olivarius, said these legislative efforts aren't extending to private employers yet, and companies should continue with DEI efforts until that time comes.

"Businesses are going to be much better off if they do the right thing morally and ethically and don't start cutting off wide swathes of people just because of their skin color or background," Olivarius said. "Do what you've always should have done: Hire the best people for the job, whether they're Black, white — it doesn't matter."

Read more: Trump ramps up campaign to dismantle DEI from corporate America

The popularity of DEI programs in the U.S. have all but tanked compared to just a few years ago, when companies of all shapes and sizes made public efforts to promote support for marginalized groups within the workforce.

A 2023 report released by Employee Benefit News surveyed roughly 670 employees to better gauge the true impact of employers' genuine commitments to DEI on staff experiences.

Roughly 75% of respondents said their employers definitely or probably have a genuine commitment to inclusion, with a greater share of employees from those in the majority reporting that their workplaces were healthier when compared to the organizations not committed to inclusivity causes.

Among the top DEI-focused efforts that were undertaken by employers, 45% reported company-wide diversity training, 40% said the creation of employee resource groups centered around specific demographics like race or gender and 37% responded with reevaluations of pay structures to better match wages with work.

Read more: DEI isn't going anywhere — but it may get a rebrand

Trump's impact on DEI across the government is still unfolding, leaving executives questioning what a similar approach in their industries could mean for employees.

Read on to stay informed on the latest changes in the diversity landscape and hear from experts on what could be next.

Donald Trump
Shawn Thew/Bloomberg

Will Trump's DEI conquest extend to reproductive benefits?

President Donald Trump's executive orders dismantling DEI in the workplace have employees wondering if reproductive benefits are next on the chopping block. Benefits experts say programs for supporting family building are safe — for now.

In speaking with EBN's Paola Peralta, Dr. Roger Shedlin, chief executive of fertility benefits provider WIN, said that such offerings will be safe from any orders and could see increased support both inside and outside the workplace in the coming months.

"We view family building and reproductive benefits as medical treatments akin to cancer treatments or broken bones," he said. "Just like those benefits wouldn't change with changes to DEI, we have not seen any sort of pull back on either existing customers who offer the benefit, or potential new customers.

Read more: Will President Trump's DEI ban affect reproductive benefits?

Signage outside of Accenture offices.
Bloomberg Mercury

Trump's DEI executive orders push Accenture to dismantle goals

The global professional services firm Accenture is abandoning its diversity benchmarks in the wake of Trump's widespread executive orders.

The goals, which were put in place by the Dublin, Ireland-based organization in 2017 and updated most recently in 2020, are being rescinded as a result of the company's "continued evaluation of [its] internal policies and practices and the evolving landscape in the United States, including recent Executive Orders," CEO Julie Sweet said in a staff memo.

Sweet said the company by and large met the goals by the 2025 deadline, which included boosting the share of women that made up its U.S. workforce to half and the percentage of managing director roles held by women to 30% across its global operations.

Read more: Accenture abandons diversity targets citing Trump's orders

amazon
Chris Ratcliffe from Bloomberg

Oklahoma legislators seek to break DEI efforts at Amazon, Alphabet

Oklahoma Treasurer Todd Russ and other officials are planning to leverage the state's investor status to launch anti-DEI shareholder proxy proposals towards Amazon, Alphabet and other major organizations.

The state invests in several organizations like Amazon and others through its $2 billion Tobacco Settlement Endowment Trust, which entitles Russ to submit proposals for instilling "political neutrality" in the companies' policies and partnerships. Other targeted organizations include Netflix, Lululemon, GoDaddy  and Yum! Brands.

"The fiduciary obligation of a publicly traded company is to maximize their earnings for their shareholders," Russ said in an interview with Bloomberg. When boards "double down on things like DEI, and that ends up in the boardroom, they muddy the waters on real fiduciary obligations."

Read more: Amazon, Alphabet targeted as Oklahoma joins anti-DEI investor ranks

Donald Trump
US President Donald Trump signs an executive order during a ceremony in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, DC, US, on Feb. 3, 2025.
Chris Kleponis/Bloomberg

How Trump is working to erase DEI from the government

Trump's quest to remove DEI programs and initiatives across the U.S. government has advanced to now ordering agency leaders to scrap efforts based on race, gender and other protected characteristics.

As per a Feb. 5 memo from the Office of Personnel Management, agencies must "eliminate DEIA offices, policies, programs and practices (including policies, programs and practices outside of any DEIA offices) that unlawfully discriminate in any employment action or other term, condition or privilege of employment," including gender, religion, age and other factors.

The orders don't include staff or divisions dedicated to "counsel[ing] employees allegedly subjected to discrimination, receiv[ing] discrimination complaints, collect[ing] demographic data and process[ing] accommodation requests," the memo said.

Read more: Trump ramps up move to scrub DEI from government

Donald Trump listens to a question while speaking to members of the media before boarding Marine One on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, D.C.
Al Drago/Bloomberg

Unpacking Trump's anti-DEI orders

Employers have so far been largely spared from Trump's wide-sweeping executive orders eroding DEI programs and unwinding a 60-year-old equal opportunity policy for federal contractors — but executives are wary that change is on the horizon.

The main argument being made by the Trump administration is the idea that DEI programs promote discrimination against white candidates in favor of more diverse talent, filling a quota rather than recognizing differences in accomplishments.

"The notion is that every person of color, women, any trans person, they're all there because of affirmative action," Ann Olivarius, women's rights attorney, chair and senior partner at McAllister Olivarius, told EBN's Deanna Cuadra. "It's so insulting and humiliating — it's an active threat against us."

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Diversity and equality Employee benefits Politics and policy
MORE FROM EMPLOYEE BENEFIT NEWS